The use of law in the destruction of indigenous religions in Canada and the United States: a comparative perspective

Stamford, Matthew Charles (2012) The use of law in the destruction of indigenous religions in Canada and the United States: a comparative perspective. Doctoral thesis (PhD), University of Sussex.

PDF - Published Version
Download (2MB) | Preview


This thesis will be a historical and comparative treatment of the way law has been applied in both an assimilative and proscriptive manner to destroy Indian religions in the United States and Canada. By producing the first such comparison, it is hoped that the emphasis on different outcomes may promote the cross-border adoption of alternative legal strategies, and ultimately provide something that may have potential as advocacy.
The Nineteenth Century saw attempts by the North American governments, often motivated by revulsion, to homogenise their native populations with illegitimate, often illegal and sometimes un-constitutional laws, aimed at the suppression of their religions. In the Twentieth Century there was less overt proscription but rather an acquisitive attitude to native cultural and sacred artefacts which continues to have a destructive impact on their religious practices. Although there have been sporadic attempts to reverse this treatment by repatriating some of these objects, such gestures have come at little governmental cost. It is the continuing restrictions on Indian prayer at sacred sites, often motivated by opposing commercial interests, which reveal the true extent of the forfeit the governments are prepared to pay.
An essential part of this study will be an investigation into how international legal doctrines that were ultimately derived from Christianity were introduced into North America to deprive the indigenous peoples of their legal rights. International Law on indigenous peoples will then be re-examined in the present era for doctrines that can be re-incorporated in order to reverse this colonisation. The seminal United Nations Declaration on Indigenous Peoples (2007), together with other more substantive and binding International Law, will be critically assessed for their potential to bolster domestic law and its ambivalent attitude to Indian religious freedom.

Item Type: Thesis (Doctoral)
Schools and Departments: School of Law, Politics and Sociology > Law
Subjects: E History America > E11 America (General) > E0075 Indians of North America
K Law > KE Law of Canada
K Law > KF Law of the United States
K Law > KF Law of the United States
Depositing User: Library Cataloguing
Date Deposited: 15 Oct 2012 14:00
Last Modified: 04 Sep 2015 15:41

View download statistics for this item

📧 Request an update