Refusing to be a man?: Men's responsibility for war rape and the problem of social structures in feminist and gender theory

Kirby, Paul (2013) Refusing to be a man?: Men's responsibility for war rape and the problem of social structures in feminist and gender theory. Men and Masculinities, 16 (1). pp. 93-114. ISSN 1097-184X

PDF - Accepted Version
Download (357kB) | Preview


As the majority perpetrators of sexual violence, it is plausible to see men as responsible for war rape not only as individuals, but also as collective bystanders, facilitators and beneficiaries. Following recent criticisms of individual legal and moral responsibility for rape as a war crime in international law, this article examines how we might think of war rape as a collective action in moral and sociological terms. First, it assesses existing moral arguments for the responsibility of men in groups for rape, primarily with reference to the work of Claudia Card, Larry May and Robert Strikwerda. Critiquing elements of these arguments, it explores the difficulties in talking about ‘men’ as a coherent group and in discussing ‘collectives’ themselves. Second, the article draws out the connection between accounts of moral responsibility and accounts of causal responsibility. Drawing on critiques of collective responsibility and the long-standing agency/structure problem, it argues that causal accounts focusing on structure pose a serious challenge to ideas of both individual and collective moral responsibility. The complexities of the relationship between moral and causal claims are illustrated through a discussion of Susan Brownmiller and Catharine MacKinnon’s influential perspectives on rape. The seeming paradox of responsibility is emphasised as a problem to be addressed by gender and feminist perspectives that seek to pursue both ethical and sociological inquiry into the workings of masculinity and the political means for undoing gendered wrongs.

Item Type: Article
Keywords: wartime sexual violence, moral responsibility, causal responsibility, masculinity, ethics, explanation, structure/agency, feminist and gender theory, gender
Schools and Departments: School of Global Studies > International Relations
Subjects: J Political Science > JZ International relations > JZ6385 The armed conflict. War and order
Depositing User: Paul Kirby
Date Deposited: 16 Nov 2012 15:39
Last Modified: 31 Jul 2017 11:34

View download statistics for this item

📧 Request an update